Tuesday, May 13, 2008
 RSS Feed | CTIA Home

Sums It All Up


You might have seen some of our postings about how unfair taxes and government fees are on wireless consumers... to the tune of more than 15% on the average bill. I think this Jeff Koterba cartoon in the Omaha World-Herald sums it all up!

Taxes - The One Real Drawback of Spring

I choose to look at it this way...in the summertime, it can get really hot.  In the fall, many of us have to rake leaves.  The winter can be dark and cold, and in the springtime, well in the springtime we all have to pay the Taxman.  Two steps forward and one big step back, especially when it comes to wireless users and the monthly taxes we pay.   As I've posted here before, the average wireless user in America pays more than 15% of his or her monthly wireless bill in government-imposed taxes and fees.  This is more than twice the amount of taxation placed on other goods and services.  
 
The Omaha World-Herald recently ran a front-page story in their Sunday edition drawing attention to this painful truth.  The St. Petersburg Times, Providence Journal and the Salt Lake Tribune have also published recent articles about the very high tax burden wireless users in those states are forced to shoulder.
 
While it's not unusual for public policy trends of decades past to haunt modern innovations of today and tomorrow, it is unusual that something hasn't yet been done about this particular policy anachronism.  Today roughly 84% of the nation uses a wireless device.   Consumers are increasingly turning to wireless for their broadband needs and wireless companies are churning out devices that allow us to perform desk-top computer functions right in the palm of our hand.   Placing sin-tax level surcharges on a service that could help America achieve its broadband penetration goal makes no sense what-so-ever.   CTIA Chairman and Verizon Wireless President and CEO Lowell McAdam summed it up best; “The wireless sector of the technology industry continues to be an important driver for growth in our nation’s economy.  Americans don’t just talk on their wireless phones anymore; they access the Internet, get information, pay bills and use wireless to be more productive at work and other every day activities. With about 15 percent of each customer’s monthly bill already going to taxes and fees, increasing discriminatory and unfair taxes on wireless customers presents a clear and present danger to future growth.  Policymakers should roll back taxes on wireless customers.”
 
And on this beautiful spring afternoon there is light at the end of the tunnel and it comes in the form of bi-partisan legislation sponsored by U.S. Representatives Zoe Lofgren (D-CA) and Chris Cannon (R-UT).   Their bill - The Cell Tax Fairness Act - grants consumers a 5-year "tax-holiday" from discriminatory state and local wireless taxes and it was introduced today in the U.S. House of Representatives.   In her press statement, Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren said;  “The Cell Tax Fairness Act will help ensure that consumers make choices about communications technology based on the merits of that technology, rather than on the rate of taxation.”       
 
I don't know about you, but this is best news I've received on Tax Day in many years.  Let's pass it!
  

I'm Feeling Taxed

Just came from the tax policy panel.  A few thoughts:

1) The fact that wireless tax rates average more than twice the average tax rate of other goods and services is simply unfair to the 255+ million American wireless consumers.

2) Wireless taxes are regressive.  That means that they affect lower-income users more than they affect those who are better-off.  What it also means is that these taxes disproportionately discourage wireless use by those that stand the most to benefit from them.

3) There is something of a disconnect between the wishes of some state governments to see wireless broadband build-out in their respective states and the necessary tax incentives/ removal of disincentives that would encourage such build out. If states’ are really serious about promoting the continued deployment of next-generation networks, their tax code should reflect that priority.

4) State tax codes are old – they were developed for the manufacturing economy of the early 20th century.  States should revamp their tax systems in order to acknowledge the shift to this new, information economy. In doing that, they would promote the well-being of these new 21rst century businesses as well encouraging their proliferation. 

That’s it from me for the day – see you all tomorrow for Day 3.

Time's Up on the Old State Tax Systems

Governing.com recently published an article entitled Growth & Taxes: Why Outdated State Tax Systems Undercut Economic Vitality, and What States Can Do About It. This article "hits the nail on the head" in concluding that most of today's state tax systems have not only failed to keep up with technology but hinder our local and national economies. Unfortunately, many state tax systems are still based on outdated views of technology which are a disservice to a state's consumers and economy. In fact, the typical wireless consumer now faces over 15% in taxes on their wireless service, more than twice the average tax rate for other goods and services. It doesn't make sense to discourage use of a service that is invaluable to citizens from all walks of life, particularly those on limited incomes, but that's exactly what happens with such exorbitant and arbitrary taxes and fees.

As Governing.com put it:

A reliable, high-quality and affordable telecommunications system is essential to the economic competitiveness of states – to say nothing of the nation. And yet, these systems are subject to very high taxation rates in a number of states – by a tax approach set when the industry, dominated by one telephone company, was highly regulated. The result is a damper on the telecom industry.

These taxing issues are germane not only to the economic vitality of a state but to its compact with taxpayers – be they individuals or businesses. The way in which revenues are raised – the fairness and transparency – is fundamental to the trust constituents have in their government. 

Don't you think it's about time state's take a fresh look at their tax systems? I do. For more information on the level of consumer taxes on wireless services in your state go to MyWireless.org.



CTIA.org Site Map | Contact Us | CTIA.org Terms Of Use | Privacy Policy | Text only
CTIA 1400 16th Street, NW, Suite 600, Washington, D.C. 20036 202.785.0081